"Wild Card" Issues

The key question underlying the 2014 QFR is “what else aren’t we seeing?” The four main QFR focus areas cover items that federal wildland fire managers consider to be of the highest priority, and how the future will look different in each of those four areas. But we also want to capture any other issues worthy of consideration. We invite you to identify any other challenges, risks, or opportunities (and related impacts) that may not fit neatly in any of the four focus areas, and may alter the way that wildland fire managers plan for and respond to wildland fires 10-20 years into the future.

What other issues–beyond the four focus areas of the 2014 QFR–may effect wildland fire management in 10-20 years?

"Wild Card" Issues

Forest Plant Communities have different fire needs

Mixed Sierran Conifer forest has understory shrubs in healthy condition. Jeffrey Pine forest understory is dominated by grasses and annual forbs. Douglas Fir forests have dense understories of shrubs. Many shrubs and all annuals and many perennials are obligate seeders, not crown resprouters, and can be extirpated by frequent ground fires. In short, the relationship of fire to these different healthy forests is different, ...more »

Submitted by (@kaytaff)

Voting

12 votes
Active

"Wild Card" Issues

Complete restructuring of forest and fire management is vital!

I am really distressed about the disconnect between forest ecology/fire ecology and the status quo of forest and fire management. These two professions work on the same issues yet worlds apart. Forest management must shift to creating more resilient ecosystems rather than waiting until there is a wildfire and sending in the cavalry. Fuels/forest management funding is constantly being cut, but wildfire may soon qualify ...more »

Submitted by (@sandra.rideouthanzak)

Voting

26 votes
Active

"Wild Card" Issues

Single Species Management

Let get away from just using and targeting fire and fuels for single species management. Fire and fuels seems to be the last resort when we talk about how we do business on a day to day in the resource world. With this current single species management mandate we seem to be the lead. How many other single species mandates have been successful in our past?

Submitted by (@khoward)

Voting

3 votes
Active

"Wild Card" Issues

Community-based Fire Management

We need to expand community engagement before, during and after fires. No more dropping into somebody's homeland for 14 days, leaving and rarely coming back to visit. The US system of firefighting was never designed to create fire adapted communities and resilient ecosystems. To achieve those, we need to integrate serious, longterm partnerships between firefighting forces and local communities . . . much more than the ...more »

Submitted by (@mhuffman)

Voting

20 votes
Active

"Wild Card" Issues

Control Future WUI Development

In the West, 84% of the WUI is yet undeveloped, the housing market has picked up once more, and with climate change as an accelerator, there is an urgent need to find solutions that impact the pattern, scale, and pace of future development in the WUI. It will be difficult to control the rising costs, damages, and dangers related to home development in the WUI unless there are negative financial consequences for private ...more »

Submitted by (@ray000)

Voting

31 votes
Active

"Wild Card" Issues

Invasive juniper species control will make a big impact

Eastern redcedar and Ashe juniper are fire intolerant native invasive species in the central US and Great Plains. Control of these species will alleviate a large host of emerging problems such as fuels management in rangelands and the WUI, water needs, human health (allergy sufferers on the rise), loss of native biodiversity, and more. Finding ways to communicate this to the public effectively is really key. The development ...more »

Submitted by (@sleis0)

Voting

2 votes
Active

"Wild Card" Issues

Sustainment Analytics for Wildland Fire Resource Managers

1. The resourcing environment facing government agencies is a complex web of interrelated decisions spanning very diverse time horizons. 2. Government agencies need to find the most effective and efficient mix of resources required to sustain their operations. 3. The complexity of the government budget environment warrants using integrated analytics for determining budgets and weighing resourcing alternatives. 4. ...more »

Submitted by (@dapeterson)

Voting

5 votes
Active

"Wild Card" Issues

Leaders need a clear text assessment of future scenarios

With today's release of the Cohesive Strategy, the timing is right to develop a succinct and clear text picture for leaders of what fire management will look like in 10 years under the new National Cohesive Strategy. This scenario should utilize updated trends from past QFRs (climate change, wui, fuels, unstable budgets, declining capability, etc...) and clearly articulate whether we can expect negative wildfire impacts ...more »

Submitted by (@segar.john)

Voting

0 votes
Active

"Wild Card" Issues

Communicating the science behind fuel treatment efficacy

Calkin etal, 2014 PNAS state: Low-elevation forests are amenable to treatments that supplement the ecological dependency on fire and also mitigate effects and spread of wildfires under extreme conditions. Fires in grasslands, shrub lands and high elevation forests do not offer mitigation opportunities that align easily with ecological requirements. With such vegetation imposed constraints on landscape management, ...more »

Submitted by (@hhaynes)

Voting

2 votes
Active

"Wild Card" Issues

Clearly defined Roles

The future of wildland fire “management” must include clear distinctions between the functions of a land management agency and the functions of an organization established for safe and effective suppression action. The past 15 years have ushered in an era of fuels management that has been of tremendous benefit for programmatic growth within the management agencies, but of dubious use for the intended purpose of reducing ...more »

Submitted by (@dluog.nhoj)

Voting

0 votes
Active